How to Find the Best Vintage Pieces, According to a Secondhand Expert

Here at Who What Wear UK, we’re all about delivering the latest and greatest shopping edits, as approved by our team. That’s why we’ve created The Joy of Shopping, a shopping column which will see me, Joy Montgomery, discussing the brands, buys, and ideas that are preoccupying my mind this month—think homewares, outerwear, and everything in-between. Is there something you’d like me to cover? Make sure to tweet or Instagram me your requests!

Like any good subculture, the vintage fashion community is one that has relished its point of difference to the rest of the world. It is a bubble that has, historically, been occupied by thrifty art students, fashion editors and eco activists, and while there was a definite sense of pride in this corner of consumerism, it has meant that secondhand has been dismissed as “alternative” by many consumers who, understandably, have become drawn to the accessibility of the fast-fashion market.

Somewhat unintentionally, I was, and still am, part of this bubble, having loved vintage fashion since I was a teenager. But now, working as a fashion journalist, I realise that this exclusivity has become a massive barrier to allowing the industry, and in turn the average consumer, to adopt more sustainable habits. So, how do we make secondhand shopping appealing and accessible to the public? It’s a question that has been playing on my mind over the last few months.

There’s a great deal to consider: From online accessibility and size diversity to the issue of scale (many vintage businesses still operate from their homes), it feels like a somewhat gargantuan task. Part of the reason I set up my Secondhand Shopper series was to challenge the idea that vintage was just for the fashion elite, through offering our readers a carefully curated edit of secondhand pieces that might just tempt you away from that high street buy. Spoiler alert: My April instalment will be a special collaboration with a mid and plus-size vintage seller, so watch this space.

With Earth Day coming up, I wanted to use my Joy of Shopping column to demystify the wonderful world of vintage, explaining the origins of my obsession and revealing my top tips for finding those pre-loved gems. Remember: None of us is perfect when it comes to shopping, and I certainly get tempted by the odd fast fashion item every now and then, but it’s all about taking baby steps and finding ways to incorporate old in with the new.

Where It All Began

As I’m sure is the case with many vintage shoppers, my love of secondhand was born out of an adolescent obsession with fashion that, unfortunately, didn’t quite match my monthly allowance. I quickly realised that if I popped into my local Oxfam, I could purchase double the amount of clothing than I could in, say, the teenage mecca that was Topshop Oxford Circus. Thanks to its affordability, I also had no qualms in unleashing my creativity on the pieces I bought, which typically meant hacking off the skirt and inexpertly stitching a new hemline. I was convinced that everything looked cooler as a micro mini. I blame Alexa Chung.

My dabbling in DIY soon turned into a full-blown hobby, which continued through university—during which I started to write about my love of vintage in my fashion blog (don’t ask)—and into my first years working in magazines. Vintage became an easy way for me to experiment with my style and try out different fashion identities. Yes, I got it very wrong sometimes (I still get flashbacks to my first fashion week where I wore a vintage tweed blazer with pleather leggings), but this creative process was integral to cementing that sense of self that now dictates my fashion choices.

When asked, one of my top shopping tips has always been to simply know—and have confidence in—your personal style, as this will help you make purchases that will stand the test of time.

Then: 2011

A photograph from one of my vintage fashion stories from my uni fashion blog. You’re very welcome.

Now: 2021

Pictured wearing my favourite checked vintage midi skirt and cowboy boots.

Fast forward eight years, and my passion for all things preloved remains steadfast. Of course, there is now the backdrop of the climate crisis to spur on my vintage evangelism, and while I wish I could say that this is the main thing keeping me shopping secondhand, if I’m honest, working within a digital landscape dominated by cookie-cutter style, it’s vintage that has kept me grounded, anchoring me to a love of fashion that isn’t uprooted by passing trends. It’s always secondhand items that draw the most compliments and add the most personality to any outfit.

Getting Started

While I could spend hours waxing lyrical about my love of vintage, I am also aware that I am a fashion editor whose job it is to think and write about clothes, and the last thing I want to do is to yell into an echo chamber of like-minded people. According to market research company GWI, 60% of consumers in the US and UK say the high cost of eco-friendly products is a barrier to purchasing them. Well, with vintage you don’t have this problem. I’m on a mission to show the mainstream shopping public that, really, it’s one of the easiest and most cost-efficient ways to make your wardrobe more sustainable.

Find a Vintage Seller or Store That Speaks Your Style Language

Thanks to the power of the internet, vintage shopping no longer has to mean rummaging through piles of old clothes in obscure charity shops. I mean, I love it, but it’s not for everyone. There is now a plethora of options to cater to everyone, whether you’re looking for styles from a particular decade (Selena’s Shop is my go-to for ’70s wares), a vintage store with a diverse range of sizes (Find By Foxes has the chicest mid and plus-size edits), pre-loved designer buys (Vestiaire Collective is the place for you), or simply a platform that offers contemporary secondhand pieces with accessible price tags (hello, One Scoop Store).

Once you’ve found a seller that speaks your language, it’s so much easier to keep returning and hunt down those wardrobe gems that will work for you. Yes, more patience is required than shopping on the high street, but I have found that this slower process helps me to buy things that I really love.


Lost Ink Ahmita UK 14 (£80)

Vintage Cream Trousers (£50)

Vintage Unisex Green Military Boilersuit (£33)

Vintage 1970s Brown Polka Dot Dress by Jean Allen (£120)

Start Out With the Basics

I have a great deal of sympathy for those who find the flamboyant frocks and psychedelic prints of your average vintage store to be intimidating. Ultimately, for secondhand to become mainstream, it needs to cater to all tastes and budgets. My recommendation is to start with the basics: Think blazers, jeans, shirts and accessories. If you find yourself in need of a new item for your wardrobe, just take a look online and see if you can find a similar style secondhand. Start by adding one pre-loved piece to an outfit, mixing old with new, and work your way up from there.


Vintage 90s Unisex Classic Trench Coat (£70)

Levis Vintage Mid Wash Denim Jeans (£45)

Vintage Red and White Long Sleeve Breton (£45)

Vintage Martha, Uk 12-16 (£40)

Always Triple-Check Sizing and Maintain High Standards

Shopping online can be a minefield at the best of times, but when you’re looking for vintage it can be even trickier, as sizing can vary massively according to the brand and what decade it was made in. It sounds obvious, but check and triple-check the measurements, and if necessary, ask the seller to supply additional info. I recently bought a pair of shorts which were the right waist size, but I could barely fit them above my thighs because I hadn’t checked the hip measurements. That being said, it is surprisingly affordable to have clothing tailored, so keep this in mind if something is a little long or needs the odd tweak.

I would also say don’t drop your standards just because something is secondhand. Of course, the odd scuff or low-level wear and tear is to be expected, but you want to make sure this is something that you will wear for many years to come. Usually, sellers are good at disclosing any imperfections, but you can always ask for more images if you want to make sure you know what you’re getting.


Vintage Green 1970’s 100% Cotton Shirt Size 8 (£35)

Vintage Orange Gingham Shirt Dress Size 14 (£28)

Vintage Cropped Suede Jacket (£125)

Vintage 1970s Disco Maxi Skirt Size 10 (£40)

Make Use of Notification Alerts to Find Specific Items

Repeat after me: Stock alerts are your friend. This is a great tactic if you’re looking for a piece from a certain brand or a particular item of clothing. Platforms such as Vestiaire Collective are super helpful when it comes to smart notifications, and you’d be surprised how many brand-new designer buys are put on these sites for half their retail value. Set an alert for a Ganni jacket, and you’ll be the first to know if someone decides to sell one. You can also set price reduction alerts, so you can keep tabs on any dream buys that are initially out of your price range.


Rejina Pyo Jacket (£127)

Ganni Silk Shirt (£64)

Dans Lente Crossbody Bag (£90)

Rixo Maxi Dress (£77)

Next: These 5 Summer Trends Look So Much Better Secondhand

This article originally appeared on Who What Wear

Read More from Who What Wear